Here’s a debate I’ve been having with a neighbor of mine: When you add on to a building that’s 90+ years old, do you have to keep the style of the older structure or are you allowed to depart from that style?
Historical Districts and codes aside, I’d like to know what people think from a personal perspective.
I view is that there should be truth in architecture and that construction should be of its time. If that means you meticulously restore a historic house and then put a modern addition on it, to me that’s acceptable. Unify styles with form, scale, and color.
My neighbor thinks that any construction connected to an older building should look like the older building. While I can see where some MAY want to go that route, I don’t agree that it is the only correct way to proceed.